In the US, the problem of community dissatisfaction with the police is pervasive. After the George Floyd murder, unquestionable demand for police reform developed. Within communities and around the country, calls of defund the police exist alongside calls to transform them. What these narratives are really expressing is the desire for significant police cultural change to occur. Right now, in the absence of a solution, what exists is the pervasive atmosphere of tension, animosity, frustration, and unmet expectations on both fronts. What is missing is the recognition that sustainable, authentic culture change needs to occur institution-wide in American policing. To do this will require both buy-in from the police and buy-in from the community, which no other solution offers. The localized nature of policing exacerbates the problem with more than 18,000 police agencies. Some solutions target single agencies but not American policing as a whole. With hopes for national police reform legislation dashed, the window of excitement closing, politics is moving on to the next issue, police reform efforts are withering and the status quo is continuing on like nothing happened. And if we don't get the police on board, we might as well just throw this whole movement away.